Tuesday, November 17, 2009

Female Sport and Sexuality

Last week in class we discussed whether or not it was ok for women athletes to pose for magazines baring a little more skin that is commonly acceptable and if their photos were really promoting their sports. I think that there are a couple underlying reasons why women expressing their sexuality is a controversial topic. The first one is that women’s sport is not nearly as popular and does not generate as much money as men’s sport. Some women have posed for photos in promotion of their sport and promotion of their athleticism. But what about the female athletes that pose more provocatively? Is it ok for them to sell sex in order to create more attention for their sport? My question is why has sport made it acceptable for women to bare all? You do not see female lawyers posing in bikini’s to promote their firms. I think that part of the reason why is that it generates money and media attention, and the media attention in most cases is positive or creates a buzz. I think that most people can agree that in world of fitness and health athletes have gorgeous bodies. Maybe promoting their bodies is a way to create fans, people who strive to achieve the fitness that the athletes have, and if you can look good while working out all the better. I still do not know if it is good for essentially promoting the sport. There is a difference in showing that your fit and a difference in sex appeal. Take David Beckham for example, he is famous for Soccer, his looks, and being married to Victoria so when I see him in underwear ads I do not think of him of promoting soccer, however, soccer does cross my mind because he has such a big face in US soccer. So in conclusion even though he is not directly promoting soccer, soccer is in association with him, and his name. Is it ok for him to pose provocatively when he represents a family sport entertainment? Yet, you do not hear about him being criticized for being in underwear ads, is it because soccer is really popular and his actions do not affect the representation of soccer as much? Or is the general public more strict with women? Does the public criticize women for going against lady like behavior, whether its for promoting their sport or not eyebrows will be raised. What I think it comes down to for most cases is that this is really some of the only media exposure that particular women sports get, some use it to increase their celebrity, however, this will be a circulating issue because I do not see a decrease in a correlation of female athletes and sex appeal in the near future.

Male Athletes and Homosexuality

Today in class we discussed about the perplexities about male athletes coming out to their professional teams when they are homosexual. In recent history most males have only come out after their professional careers were over to avoid being ostracized with their fans and even within their own team. Even with the strides we have made in recent years for gay rights and the acceptance of gays within the community, male athletes who are gay may have it a little harder than the majority. Their profession revolves around masculinity, and it doesn’t help their case that there is a connotation that gay men tend to be more feminine. I think because of the nature of their job and the negative reputation of the homosexuality, the atmosphere of and a gay male athlete and his counterparts are intensified. If a professional athlete were to come out that he was gay, I think he will have a support system, however, I also think that he will have a hard time maintaining expectance from the rest of his teams and his fans. I totally understand that for wanting to wait to come out until their career is over. Until there has been a substantial number of athletes that come out later in life, people will finally start to break down their pre conceptions and expectations of athletes and heterosexuality. And until that happens I think it will be unlikely that we will hear about gay male athletes that come out while in the duration of their career.

Sunday, November 8, 2009

Women with MUSCLE

In class we got into a discussion on how much muscle is too much muscle that is acceptable for a woman. I found this interesting, because I myself have my preferences about how much muscle I like on a man or how much muscle I think is attractive on a woman, however, I never considered an amount of muscle mass being inappropriate or not right. Working within the fitness culture I have found that those who work to compete in fitness and body building competitions are apart of this close knit subculture. Even, a lot of muscle on a man in class was considered to be unattractive, however, I do not think men will ever be ostracized by society such as some women may be who are apart of the body building subculture. To those who compete in body building view large muscles as beautiful and a healthy way of living, and I do not think that they should be judged on their appearance for that. It is not as if they are making their appearance offensive to others or that their looks would be deemed inappropriate in certain social settings such as a conservative atmosphere. I just feel that its sexist that women who have taken apart of the body building lifestyle are deemed inappropriate as apposed to men who, were not thought of as inappropriate, just not attractive to those who do not like the body building type. It just may take time before women may reach the same type of criticisms as men, however, you can not deny that there are different standards and expectations for men and women and that maybe women are criticized more for joining the body building world because it has never been accepted that women posses a masculine trait. However, I do believe that times are changing and people are being more open because we already see more women playing football, but who knows if women will ever truly be equal to men in terms of masculinity.

Indian Wells and the William Sisters

I never really understood the Indian Wells incident until we discussed it in class, and I completely side with the Williams sisters with their decision in not returning to play in future tournaments. I understand that it is not so much the crowds reaction and their inappropriate display of resentment towards the Williams family, its the fact that the tournament staff did not do anything to fix their mistakes and prevent future outrage with the fans. First of all, I agree that Indian Wells should have confessed to their ticket holders that they were late in informing them that Serena could not participate in her match. Because they did not do that one simple action it was the cause of a whole set of events that are much harder to control, such as a mass crowed of angry tennis fans. I do believe that they could have done other actions to protect their players, such as security warning their rude and intolerable fans to watch their language and if they didn't they would be escorted out of the venue and be given a refund. Or even the tournament director making an announcement to kindly ask people to keep their etiquette during the match or even confessing their mistake. The tournament director has control to do what he wants, it is his tournament, it would not be hard to get a microphone and address the crowd. There were many opportunities to help resolve the problem or even to cut some of the tension. However, because they did not, they disrespected the Williams family and let the situation get so out of control that they had a upset stadium that would be nearly impossible to settle down. Since this is the one tournament that a lot of the Williams family and friends could easily attend, I highly doubt that racial slurs would prevent them from returning. Again, it was how the was run, who would want to play in a tournament that doesn't take care of their athletes and does not have control of their own operations. Maybe one day when there is a new director and the tournament is under different management the sisters will return to play.

Thursday, October 1, 2009

Equality within Sport

Recently we have been discussing equality, Title IX, and should females be able to participate in male athletics. The general consensus was mixed. I personally felt that if a females should be able to participate in a sport that is not available to them, and vise versa. There is a lot of controversy about how title IX in sports was mainly meant to help advance female equality in athletics, however, I think people tend to forget that’s its a new day and a new age. Yes, title IX was created only a few decades ago, but I believe that alterations need to be kept up with the times. Title IX wasn’t even meant to have a huge impact on sports when it was first created, so I do not think we can discriminate on a policy because it was, "supposed" or "meant" to advance women in sport. When rules and regulations were made within individual athletic programs, women wanting to compete in men’s sports and men wanting to compete in female sport most, likely was never considered to be an option. Well again, times have changed, and we must keep up. If there is not an opportunity for a male to play field hockey then he should have the chance to play on the women’s team if he qualifies in skill. I understand where is coach was coming from. Her job is to create a team that will win games, if a male can bring a contribution to the team then he should be able to compete. Also with a male wanting to play field hockey, it will probably spring interest from others, and eventually could develop the sport and grow it’s popularity. Coaching lacrosse, it was important not only to win games but to develop an interest and a love for the game that will allow current athletes to give back to the sport the following years, growing the sport. Who knows that one male athlete that played on the women’s field hockey team may give back to the sport weather he is a coach or a huge donator to their national association, allowing more teams to be created, who knows, he may spring enough publicity that male teams will spring up across the country. The parents that were salty were probably parents of children who’s playing time was cut because another athlete had more skill. Trust me, as a head varsity coach if someone’s child is not fed with a silver spoon, they will find anything to find someone who is responsible for their, “star” child not getting as much playing time. Again, we are continually advancing in equal rights and rules and regulations need to be altered in order to keep up and further advancement.

Thursday, September 17, 2009

Hermaphrodites and Athletics

Caster Semenya is exploding all over the media with the recent discovery that she is a hermaphrodite.  Semenya has no ovaries or uterus and does have internal testes that produce large amounts of testosterone, which would explain her deep voice and her physical shape.  This is a new debate that is very interesting to me because this has never really been a problem before in athletes nor have we had to technology to diagnose those in question.  Semenya with male traits and testosterone running through her body would be the debate that would give a bigger advantage to other female runners.  I say if we are going to get technical with the amount of testosterone in someones body then we need to look at the genetic makeup of every single participant of that athletic competition.  Yes testosterone is defiantly going to give a female athlete an advantage over others, however, how can we not exclude other female athletes whos genetic makeup is very athletic and similar to that a of a male body, which would give them an advantage to a competitor who isnt.  That is my opinion but who is to say that a female is too male, and a male is too female.  This i believe is going to be a long ongoing debate for those who are a hermaphrodite.  I mean who is to judge someones gender preference and disregard it because it would be an unfair competition.  again, if its going to be looked into that closely then I think that other factors must be taken into affect as well.

Serena's Outburst

Okay,  so Serena had a melt down when a footfall was called and she reacted in a manner that upset most.  I would have to say when I first saw the video clip I laughed and found it humorous.  I think I reacted this way because this was outside of her character and is one of the most respected and notable female athletes of our time.  She already has established a favorable reputation with the public.  I think a lot of people had a similar reaction to her rage like mine, however, there were a lot who viewed her actions as, "un lady like".  Especially in a prestigious country club sport like tennis, that behavior is unacceptable.  Even as a lacrosse coach if one of my girls acted out like that to a referee she would be suspended from that game and the next.  I think if it were a male that reacted the way she did, it would be a little more accepted but not by much. Instead of being unlady like I think he would become a little unfavorable, yet, his actions would just reflect what our society percieves our male athletes to be; dominant, masculine, and aggressive.  Ya he may get the, jerk, vibe from a lot of his female friends, yet, he may be praised by his males fans.  I believe it is a little harder to come out of a situation like Serena's solely because she is a women and we as a society have different expectations and standards that women must uphold.

As far as her punishment, I do not believe that she should be suspended from her next tournament.  Being at the elite professional level that she is at, I think that suspending her is a little ridiculous. It is not as if she went chasing after the line judge with her racket.  I would think that there might be rules forbidding players to speak to a line judge in a negative manner or any official at that.  Her punishment was a fine, yet I would think that her actions would result in points taken away from her game or her complete ranking as an individual player. I am not excusing her from her actions, but I think all of the negative publicity is enough to think before she speaks again. Again, who knows what the consequences and the reaction of the publicity might be if a male player were to react the same way in that particular situation.  I think across the board in tennis it would have been looked down upon, yet I can not decide if the male would have been viewed as more threatening and would have recieved a harsher punishment or if his actions would have been slightly more acecpted due to the fact he has testosterone running through his blood.